Viewing the Emergent City and Its People

Failed Cities – The Ruins of Detroit via The Economist

Posted on The Economist website recently this interview “Up from the ashes”

YVES MARCHAND and Romain Meffre, two self-taught French photographers, have always been fascinated by ruins. After seeing photos of the formerly prosperous North American town of Detroit in 2005, they realised it would be a perfect place to work.

Detroit was one of most important American cities in the 20th century. But over the past generation it has suffered perhaps the worst economic downturn of any American city. Schools, libraries, theatres hotels and concert halls that were once sources of pride now stand empty and unloved. Some are being torn down, others are merely crumbling with neglect. Others still, especially in the downtown area, have been purchased by millionaires with plans for renovation, but the process has been a slow one.”

Yet Detroit is slowly rising from its ashes. Marchand and Meffre say there are plans to convert quite a few of the downtown buildings into lofts and luxury condominiums in the next ten years. But parts of the city are clearly breathing their last gasp. Marchand and Meffre’s book “The Ruins of Detroit“, originally a series for Time magazine, records the lost city of Detroit for posterity. The two photographers spoke to More Intelligent Lifeabout their inspiration for this book.

What is it about “ruins” that you find so alluring?

When a building is abandoned, in some way it’s escaping from us, from our human context. It’s like it’s slipping into another reality. We try to depict that. Ruins and buildings are really good metaphors for human nature, for our ability to create and destroy.

A fading and rotting building reminds you how fluctuating and ephemeral things are. Ruins are a kind of humanisation of architecture. Their fragility brings them closer to us. They turn structures that can be perceived as inanimate and cold into something really moving. The Michigan train station for instance is even more iconic as a ruin than if it was clean and painted white.”

What were the most distressing photos you had to take?

The most distressing pictures we made were probably those of the schools and libraries full of books. Even if you know the context, you really don’t get why it has been left like that, and it says a lot about the loss of culture, lack of education and social waste. This is the great paradox of these ruins. They are not empty but full of objects. It’s like consumerism being applied to a whole building, to a whole city; it’s a kind of industrial logic of replacement and abandonment. Once a building is useless (when there is a new one in the suburbs or even just next to it for instance) you just throw the old one away, like a disposable product. It’s a kind of misery within the abundance and that’s what is really troubling.”

“Was it also a hopeful experience? Decline often gives way to rebirth.

Of course, it’s a cycle. Unfortunately the city stayed a little bit longer on the wrong side of the loop compared to some others. Detroit has a very short and violent history, it rose to the very top in 50 years, and fell to the very bottom within 50 years as well. It would not be a surprise to see it rise again. We are optimistic. If a building is still standing, it has the hope of being reused.”

The Ruins of Detroit, published by Steidl, is out now

From website  where more images can be seen:

“At the end of the XIXth Century, mankind was about to fulfill an old dream. The idea of a fast and autonomous means of displacement was slowly becoming a reality for engineers all over the world. Thanks to its ideal location on the Great Lakes Basin, the city of Detroit was about to generate its own industrial revolution. Visionary engineers and entrepreneurs flocked to its borders.

In 1913, up-and-coming car manufacturer Henry Ford perfected the first large-scale assembly line. Within few years, Detroit was about to become the world capital of automobile and the cradle of modern mass-production. For the first time of history, affluence was within the reach of the mass of people. Monumental skyscapers and fancy neighborhoods put the city’s wealth on display. Detroit became the dazzling beacon of the American Dream. Thousands of migrants came to find a job. By the 50’s, its population rose to almost 2 million people. Detroit became the 4th largest city in the United States.

The automobile moved people faster and farther. Roads, freeways and parking lots forever reshaped the landscape. At the beginning of the 50’s, plants were relocated in Detroit’s periphery. The white middle-class began to leave the inner city and settled in new mass-produced suburban towns. Highways frayed the urban fabric. Deindustrialization and segregation increased. In 1967, social tensions exploded into one of the most violent urban riots in American history. The population exodus accelerated and whole neighbourhoods began to vanish. Outdated downtown buildings emptied. Within fifty years Detroit lost more than half of its population.

Detroit, industrial capital of the XXth Century, played a fundamental role shaping the modern world. The logic that created the city also destroyed it. Nowadays, unlike anywhere else, the city’s ruins are not isolated details in the urban environment. They have become a natural component of the landscape. Detroit presents all archetypal buildings of an American city in a state of mummification. Its splendid decaying monuments are, no less than the Pyramids of Egypt, the Coliseum of Rome, or the Acropolis in Athens, remnants of the passing of a great Empire.

This work is thus the result of a five-year collaboration started in 2005.”



Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s